Elmo Plush

There are two elmo plushes in the show, there's Zachary's Elmo Plush, and then there's the Classroom Elmo Plush, owned by Ms. Scott at the school in the show

Zachary's Elmo Plush appears both in the dreams and in the real world but the other one in the classroom (the one with small eyes, hence the show's name) only exists in the dreams, and he is seen wearing an old sun hat and old western clothing and black boots. This elmo puppet plush is also older than both Zachary, and his elmo plush.